Phil and Carol retry their attempts at having a kid with a sperm donor.
Season: 02 Episode: 16
Total Episode Count: 29
Prod. no.: 2AYB16
First Aired: April 24, 2016
Guest Starring: Jason Sudeikis
Featuring: Phil Miller, Mike Miller, Carol Pilbasian, Todd
Also Appearing: Gail Klosterman, Erica, Melissa Chartres
Musical Numbers: Falling Slowly
Director: David Noel
: David Noel
, John Solomon Plot
After asking Todd to be a sperm donor, Carol tells Phil about it, however, he is unsure but later accepts. When Phil tells Mike this, Mike is confused about what is happening, which eventually leads to Phil telling Mike he's never said "I love you" to Carol. Later that day, Carol and Todd have their wedding ceremony with Phil officiating it. At the wedding, Carol temporarily divorces Phil, but during the vows, Todd mentions Phil is like a brother, which causes Phil to object the wedding and ask Mike to be the sperm donor.
Despite Todd saying he is okay with it, Todd is visibly upset with Phil at the after-party. Phil attempts to console him but Todd continues to say that he is okay with it. Meanwhile, Mike and Carol have begun to bond, much to the dismay of Phil. In order to prevent them from falling in love, Phil gives them suits to wear for them to have sex and additionally says that he'll be watching them as well. Despite Mike not wanting to go through with, Phil convinces him to, but Mike and Carol's picnic themed talking during sex causes him to be annoyed and admit that he loves Carol, much to her happiness and Mike's annoyance.
The following morning, Phil notices Todd is still acting strange and has shaved his entire head and has continued to show attitude towards Phil. Carol then comes and brings out what she thinks is an ovulation test, but is actually a pregnancy test. After Erica reads it, the pregnancy test shows positive. As the group expresses happiness, Phil congratulates Mike for completing the job, but Mike tells him that it's his child, much to Phil's excitement. After celebrating, Gail heads outside to relax and drink some wine, where she then notices a flying drone spying on her.