After reuniting with his brother, Phil throws a party for the group to celebrate.
Season: 02 Episode: 14
Total Episode Count: 27
Prod. no.: 2AYB14
First Aired: April 10, 2016
Guest Starring: Jason Sudeikis
Featuring: Phil Miller, Mike Miller
Also Appearing: Todd, Carol Pilbasian, Melissa Chartres, Gail Klosterman, Erica
Musical Numbers: Space Oddity, We Didn't Start the Virus
Director: Claire Scanlon
Writers: Kira Kalush, Matt Marshall
Plot: After Phil punches Mike in the groin, Phil continues to fight Mike over a past crush between the both of them named Christine, but when Mike points out that he's thought about Phil for years, the two brothers hug it out and reunite with happiness. Over dinner, Mike explains how he made it to Malibu, which eventually turns into Mike revealing some embarassing things about Phil's past. Mike then questions why the group is calling him Tandy, which leads to Mike revealing Phil's childhood nickname, Skidmark.
The next day, the group continues to call Phil by his embarassing nickname, much to Phil's dismay, which then leads Phil to show them his skidmark free underwear. Afterwards, Mike invites everyone to a bonfire where Mike sings a song, which eventually leads to Phil getting jealous of Mike. In order to regain his popularity, Phil decides to throw a party, but none of them show up. When the group eventually does, he begins to sing, but when Mike begins to joke around, Phil begins to get ticked at him and soon explain Mike's faults, leading Mike to go home and vow to get even with him. That night, Carol forces Phil to apologize the next day, but when Phil wakes up in the morning, it is revealed that Mike shaved off entirely half of Phil's body and face.
Meanwhile, Gail, Erica, and Melissa decline Todd's proposal for a four-some, leading Todd to apologize about it. The next day, Melissa and Gail talk about recent events, and admit that they do love Todd, leading them to agree to simultaneously date Todd, much to Todd's happiness.