Phil devises an escape plan to get away from Pamela.
Season: 04 Episode: 02
Total Episode Count: 51
Prod. no.: 4AYB02
First Aired: October 8, 2017
Guest Starring: Kristen Wiig, Chris Elliott
Featuring: Phil Miller, Pamela Brinton, Glenn
Also Appearing: Carol Pilbasian, Melissa Chartres, Todd Rodriguez, Erica Dundee, Gail Klosterman, Jasper, Jeremy
Musical Numbers: Sailing
Director: David Noel
: Megan Ganz
, Tim McAuliffe Plot
Pamela attempts to try and get Phil to fall in love with her, who is still being held hostage. After learning about "Stockholm syndrome", Phil tries to trick Pamela, when she isn't around, by making her believe that he no longer has interest in Carol. They sing a rendition of "Sailing", but Pamela reveals that she knows it was all a trick and holds him at gunpoint and tells Phil to stop what he is doing or risk being shot.
As he talks to himself, he thinks of Carol in everything he sees, including a toenail cutter that inspires him to use his "razor sharp" toenails to cut free. He escapes and plans to use a fire extinguisher to distract Pamela and take her gun, but fails and improvises to protect himself by threatening to throw Jeremy overboard and to eat him. His plan works, but notices that they are no longer in sight of the island.
Meanwhile, the group is stranded on an island, where they try to make the best of their little supplies, before encountering a castaway named Glenn on the island. Glenn introduces them to his living situation, where they find his sex doll and discover that he is completely unaware that the virus happened. Later on, they try to tell him, but with his hopes and intentions to see his family again, they decide not to.
Carol worries about never seeing Phil again. Glenn comes to her and reveals that he has a signal fire, but is saving it for a boat or plane. She reveals to him that the entire world was wiped out. He confesses later that night to Carol that he was foolish, but she insists that he was hopeful. They decide to light the signal fire, which covers a big portion of the island. Pamela also feels guilt about what she did to Phil and the others, and spots the signal fire in the distance. Phil and Carol reunite the next day as the group contemplates on what to do with Pamela. The majority of them agree to leave her on the island, as she pleads the group to take Jeremy with them. Glenn notes that she will have no hope of being rescued and decide to bring Pamela with them anyway, but on the condition that she rides connected to the boat in the dingy.